Back to all blogs

What is Smart Proctoring? Everything You Need To Know About

What is Smart Proctoring? Everything You Need To Know About

Learn what smart proctoring is, how it works, its types, features, benefits, challenges, and best practices for secure and fair online examinations.

By

By

Abhishek Kaushik

Abhishek Kaushik

Published on

Published on

Add Sherlock as a preferred source on Google

Online examinations allow universities, certification providers, and employers to assess candidates without requiring them to visit physical testing centers. However, conducting examinations remotely raises important concerns about candidate identity, examination security, monitoring practices, and the reliability of assessment results.

How can organizations verify that the registered candidate is taking the examination? How can they identify potential rule violations? And how should administrators investigate suspicious activities without unfairly affecting legitimate candidates?

Smart proctoring helps address these challenges by combining digital monitoring tools, identity verification, examination controls, and, in some cases, artificial intelligence (AI). Depending on the platform, human proctors may supervise candidates in real time, review recorded sessions, or investigate automated alerts.

A 2021 EDUCAUSE analysis of 2,155 college and university websites in the United States and Canada found references to proctoring software on 62.9% of them during November 2020. Although this does not represent current global adoption, it highlights the presence of remote proctoring technologies in higher education at that time.

However, automated monitoring cannot independently confirm examination misconduct. Technical interruptions, background noise, and normal candidate behavior may generate alerts that require human review. Organizations must also consider privacy, accessibility, technical reliability, and transparent examination policies.

This guide explains what smart proctoring is, how it works, its types, key features, benefits, applications, and challenges. It also explores how organizations can choose and implement suitable proctoring solutions while maintaining examination integrity and ensuring a fair assessment experience.

What Is Smart Proctoring?

Smart proctoring is a technology-based approach to monitoring and supervising examinations, particularly in remote assessment environments. Depending on the platform, it may combine digital monitoring tools, artificial intelligence (AI), automated examination controls, and human supervision to help educational institutions, certification providers, and employers maintain examination integrity.

Unlike traditional proctoring, where an invigilator physically supervises candidates in an examination hall, smart proctoring allows administrators to oversee assessments through an online platform. Depending on the system, it may include identity verification, webcam monitoring, screen activity tracking, audio analysis, and browser restrictions to identify activities that may violate examination rules.

Practical Example: Consider an online certification exam that requires a candidate to remain alone in a room. If another face appears in the webcam feed, the system may flag the event. A reviewer then checks the recording and examination rules to decide whether the event needs further investigation. The software can identify an observable event, but it cannot independently establish that unauthorized assistance occurred.

Smart proctoring therefore supports examination supervision by documenting relevant activities and helping administrators investigate potential violations. Its effectiveness depends on appropriate monitoring configurations, reliable technology, and fair human review procedures.

Smart proctoring infographic showing online exam monitoring, identity verification, screen tracking, audio analysis, and browser restrictions.

How Does Smart Proctoring Work?

Smart proctoring follows a structured process that begins with candidate verification and continues through examination monitoring and incident review. The exact steps depend on the assessment requirements, platform capabilities, and monitoring permissions. Each stage helps establish examination conditions, identify potential rule violations, and support informed decisions.

1. Verify the Candidate

The process begins when a candidate signs in using an authorized account or examination invitation. Depending on the assessment requirements, the platform may request an identity document, facial image, or live camera capture to compare against registered information.

Some systems also perform additional identity checks during the examination to confirm that the registered candidate remains present. However, successful identity verification only establishes confidence in the candidate's identity and does not guarantee compliance with examination rules.

2. Prepare the Examination Environment

Before the examination begins, the system checks whether the candidate's device meets the necessary technical requirements. These checks may include webcam functionality, microphone access, internet connectivity, browser compatibility, and screen-sharing permissions.

Candidates may also be asked to complete an environmental scan to identify unauthorized materials or additional electronic devices, where permitted by examination policies. Clear instructions should explain the purpose of these checks and help candidates resolve technical issues before starting.

3. Monitor Permitted Activities

During the examination, smart proctoring software monitors selected activities according to predefined examination rules. Depending on the platform, monitoring may include webcam presence, audio signals, screen activity, and interactions with examination applications.

Some platforms also integrate secure browsers that restrict access to unauthorized websites, applications, or system functions. These restrictions help enforce examination rules, while monitoring tools collect information that may require further investigation.

4. Record Potential Rule Violations

When the system detects an activity that matches a configured monitoring condition, it may generate an alert or record an event with a timestamp. Depending on the platform, flagged activities may include the appearance of an additional person, repeated interruptions in webcam visibility, or attempts to access restricted applications.

The platform may organize these events into an examination report, allowing administrators to locate relevant recordings or activity logs. However, a flagged event does not automatically establish misconduct, as technical problems or legitimate candidate behavior may produce similar alerts.

5. Review the Available Evidence

After the examination, or during a live monitoring session, authorized reviewers assess flagged activities using available recordings, event logs, and examination rules. They examine the circumstances surrounding each incident to determine whether further investigation is necessary.

Where an examination outcome could be affected, reviewers should consider relevant candidate explanations and apply consistent decision-making standards. Organizations should also provide a documented process for candidates to question or appeal findings, helping ensure that decisions are based on evidence rather than automated alerts alone.

Types of Smart Proctoring

Smart proctoring can be categorized into three main types based on how examination sessions are supervised and reviewed. These include live proctoring, recorded proctoring, and automated proctoring. Each approach differs in its level of human involvement, monitoring capabilities, and method of identifying potential examination rule violations.

1. Live Proctoring

Live proctoring involves human invigilators supervising candidates in real time through webcams, microphones, and, where supported, screen sharing. Proctors observe examination activities, identify potential rule violations, and communicate directly with candidates when intervention is necessary.

This approach enables immediate responses to suspicious activities, technical difficulties, or examination-related concerns. However, it requires dedicated personnel throughout the examination, which can increase operational costs when supervising large numbers of candidates.

2. Recorded Proctoring

Recorded proctoring captures examination sessions for review after the assessment has been completed. Depending on the platform, recordings may include webcam footage, audio, and screen activity. Trained reviewers examine these records to identify potential violations of examination rules.

Unlike live proctoring, this approach does not require continuous human supervision during the examination. However, reviewing recordings can be time-consuming, particularly when organizations conduct large numbers of assessments.

3. Automated Proctoring

Automated proctoring uses artificial intelligence (AI) and predefined detection rules to monitor examination activities without continuous human supervision. Depending on the platform, it may identify multiple faces appearing on camera, unusual audio activity, or attempts to access restricted applications.

The system generates alerts or flags potentially suspicious events for further evaluation. This approach can support large-scale examinations and reduce manual monitoring requirements. However, automated detection may produce inaccurate alerts, making appropriate human review procedures important before determining whether misconduct has occurred.

Key Features of Smart Proctoring

Smart proctoring platforms offer various features to support candidate verification, examination monitoring, and incident review. These capabilities help organizations maintain examination integrity while managing remote assessments. However, the availability and functionality of individual features may vary across platforms.

Smart proctoring features including identity verification, exam monitoring, incident documentation, automated alerts, and administrative controls.

1. Identity and Session Controls

Identity and session controls help ensure that the registered candidate can access the examination and that their device meets the necessary technical requirements before the assessment begins.

  • Account authentication: Verifies that candidates access the examination through authorized credentials or invitations.

  • Identity verification: May use identification documents, facial recognition, or biometric checks to compare candidate information with registration records.

  • Device compatibility checks: Assess whether the camera, microphone, internet connection, and required software are functioning correctly.

2. Monitoring and Examination Controls

Monitoring features help identify activities that may violate examination rules, while examination controls restrict certain actions during the assessment. The specific monitoring methods depend on the platform and examination requirements.

  • Webcam monitoring: May detect candidates leaving the camera frame or additional individuals appearing during the examination.

  • Screen activity tracking: Records specified computer activities, including application switching or navigation outside the examination window.

  • Secure browser integration: Restricts access to selected websites, applications, or system functions during the assessment.

3. Incident Documentation

Incident documentation features help examination administrators investigate flagged activities and maintain records of relevant events. These records provide supporting evidence for reviewing potential violations rather than automatically confirming misconduct.

  • Timestamped event logs: Record detected activities and help reviewers identify relevant moments during an examination.

  • Recorded examination evidence: May preserve webcam footage, audio, or screen recordings for authorized review, subject to applicable privacy requirements.

  • Administrative reports: Summarize flagged events and examination activities to support consistent incident review and documentation.

4. Automated Alerts and Activity Flagging

Automated alerts help examination administrators identify activities that may require additional attention during or after an assessment. Depending on the platform, these systems use predefined rules or AI-based analysis to detect events that differ from permitted examination conditions.

  • Real-time alerts: Notify proctors when configured monitoring conditions are triggered, allowing them to examine potential issues during an examination.

  • Activity flagging: Identifies events such as unexpected camera interruptions, additional individuals appearing on screen, or attempts to access restricted applications.

  • Event prioritization: Helps administrators organize flagged incidents according to predefined criteria so that relevant examination activities can be reviewed efficiently.

Automated alerts support examination monitoring but should not be treated as definitive evidence of misconduct without appropriate contextual review.

5. Proctoring Dashboard and Administrative Controls

A proctoring dashboard provides administrators with a centralized interface for managing examination sessions, reviewing monitoring information, and coordinating supervision activities. Its capabilities depend on the platform and the permissions assigned to different users.

  • Session management: Allows authorized administrators to monitor examination progress and access relevant session information.

  • Configurable examination settings: Enables organizations to define permitted activities, monitoring requirements, and examination-specific restrictions.

  • Role-based access: Restricts access to candidate information, examination recordings, and administrative functions according to assigned responsibilities.

These features help organizations manage multiple examination sessions while maintaining appropriate control over monitoring activities and candidate information.

Benefits of Smart Proctoring

Smart proctoring offers several advantages for educational institutions, certification providers, and employers conducting online assessments. By combining remote supervision, digital monitoring, and examination records, it can improve assessment accessibility and help administrators manage examination activities more efficiently.

1. Greater Accessibility and Flexibility

Smart proctoring allows candidates to take supervised examinations from approved remote locations without traveling to physical testing centers. This makes assessments more accessible to candidates living in different cities or regions while reducing travel costs and logistical challenges.

Remote assessments can also provide greater scheduling flexibility, depending on the examination provider's policies. However, candidates still need compatible devices, reliable internet connectivity, and an appropriate testing environment.

2. Improved Examination Monitoring and Documentation

Smart proctoring systems can record examination activities and maintain digital evidence to support the investigation of potential rule violations. Depending on the platform, these records may include webcam footage, screen activity, timestamps, and automated alerts.

These records help administrators examine specific incidents, understand the circumstances surrounding flagged activities, and make more informed decisions. They can also support the review of disputed examination outcomes, provided the information is securely stored and accessed only by authorized personnel.

3. Efficient Examination Administration

Smart proctoring can help organizations manage large-scale online assessments by reducing the need for continuous manual supervision. Automated monitoring tools can identify events requiring attention, allowing administrators to prioritize examination sessions that need further review.

This approach can reduce the time spent reviewing routine examination activity and help administrators allocate resources more effectively. However, the efficiency gained depends on the accuracy of automated alerts, the volume of flagged events, and the amount of human review required.

4. Consistent Application of Examination Rules

Smart proctoring allows organizations to configure monitoring conditions and examination controls according to established assessment policies. Applying standardized settings across examination sessions can help reduce inconsistencies in how certain activities are monitored and documented.

For example, an institution may configure the same browser restrictions, identity verification requirements, and event-logging procedures for candidates taking a particular examination. This helps establish consistent supervision conditions across different locations.

However, consistent monitoring does not automatically guarantee fair outcomes. Organizations must still consider approved accommodations, technical limitations, and individual circumstances when reviewing potential violations.

5. Reduced Examination Logistics and Operational Costs

Smart proctoring can reduce some of the logistical requirements associated with conducting examinations at physical testing centers. By allowing candidates to complete supervised assessments remotely, organizations may reduce the need for examination venues, on-site invigilators, and related administrative arrangements.

This can be particularly useful for institutions and employers assessing candidates across multiple geographic locations. Centralized examination management may also simplify scheduling, coordination, and supervision.

However, potential cost savings depend on platform licensing fees, technical support requirements, monitoring methods, and the resources needed for human review. Organizations should evaluate these factors to determine whether remote proctoring offers operational advantages for their assessment programs.

Where Is Smart Proctoring Used?

Smart proctoring is used across educational institutions, certification programs, recruitment processes, and corporate training. However, monitoring requirements vary depending on the assessment's purpose, examination rules, and the consequences of the results.

Smart proctoring applications in higher education, professional certification, recruitment assessments, and corporate learning.

1. Higher Education

Universities may use smart proctoring to supervise online course examinations, entrance tests, and academic assessments. It helps institutions monitor examination conditions while allowing students to participate remotely.

  • Remote examination supervision: Enables universities to monitor students taking examinations outside traditional examination centers.

  • Customizable examination rules: Allows institutions to configure monitoring requirements based on permitted materials, examination policies, and approved accessibility accommodations.

2. Professional Certification

Professional certification bodies may use smart proctoring to verify candidate identities and supervise examinations that lead to industry-recognized qualifications. This helps maintain consistent assessment standards across different testing locations.

  • Candidate identity verification: Helps confirm that the registered individual is taking the certification examination.

  • Examination integrity: Supports the documentation and review of potential rule violations before certification decisions are made.

3. Recruitment Assessments

Employers may use smart proctoring during online aptitude tests, technical evaluations, and other pre-employment assessments. It supports the administration of supervised assessments when candidates participate from different locations.

  • Remote candidate assessments: Enables employers to conduct supervised hiring tests without requiring candidates to visit a physical assessment center.

  • Assessment-specific monitoring: Allows organizations to select appropriate controls while accommodating approved assistive technologies and accessibility requirements.

4. Corporate Learning

Organizations may use smart proctoring to supervise internal training evaluations, compliance assessments, and employee certification programs. The level of monitoring can vary depending on the importance of the assessment.

  • Compliance assessments: Help organizations supervise mandatory training evaluations where independent completion is required.

  • Employee skill validation: Supports the verification of individual knowledge and competency through supervised internal assessments.

Smart Proctoring vs. Traditional Proctoring

Both smart proctoring and traditional proctoring aim to maintain examination integrity by supervising assessment conditions and identifying potential rule violations. However, they differ in how supervision is conducted, where examinations take place, and what evidence can be retained.

Traditional proctoring typically relies on invigilators physically observing candidates in an examination venue. Smart proctoring uses digital monitoring tools and, where applicable, remote human supervision to oversee assessments conducted outside conventional testing centers.

Neither approach guarantees the detection of every examination rule violation.

Comparison of the Two Approaches

Factor

Smart Proctoring

Traditional Proctoring

Location

Often conducted remotely

Usually conducted at a physical examination venue

Observation

Uses digital monitoring feeds, activity logs, and/or remote human supervision

Uses in-person invigilators

Records

May retain recordings, event timestamps, and examination activity logs

Often relies on invigilator observations and incident notes

Requirements

Requires compatible devices, internet connectivity, and appropriate software

Requires examination venues, travel arrangements, and on-site staffing

Limitations

May involve technical errors, privacy concerns, and ambiguous automated alerts

May involve human observation limitations and venue-related constraints

The choice between smart and traditional proctoring depends on the examination's purpose, security requirements, available resources, and candidate needs. Organizations should evaluate both approaches based on their ability to support reliable supervision, fair assessment decisions, and an appropriate examination experience.

Challenges and Limitations of Smart Proctoring

Although smart proctoring can support online examination integrity, it also presents technical, privacy, and fairness challenges. Organizations must understand these limitations and establish appropriate safeguards to ensure that monitoring systems operate reliably without creating unnecessary difficulties for candidates.

1. Detection Errors

Smart proctoring systems may generate false positives, where legitimate activities are incorrectly flagged, or false negatives, where actual rule violations go undetected. Background speech, poor lighting, and camera interruptions can affect detection accuracy.

How to prevent or minimize detection errors:

  • Regularly test detection systems under different lighting, audio, and device conditions to identify potential performance issues.

  • Require human review of significant alerts before determining whether examination misconduct has occurred.

2. Privacy and Data Protection

Smart proctoring may involve collecting sensitive information, including webcam recordings, audio, identification documents, and screen activity. Inadequate security measures or excessive data collection can expose candidates to privacy risks.

How to protect candidate privacy:

  • Collect only the information necessary for examination supervision and clearly inform candidates about monitoring practices.

  • Apply appropriate encryption, access restrictions, and data retention policies to protect examination records from unauthorized access.

3. Accessibility and Fairness

Candidates with disabilities may require assistive technologies, movement breaks, or alternative examination arrangements. Standard monitoring rules may incorrectly flag these activities if approved accommodations are not considered.

How to ensure accessibility and fairness:

  • Provide reasonable accommodations and alternative assessment arrangements based on individual accessibility requirements.

  • Configure monitoring rules to account for approved accommodations and establish procedures for reviewing disputed alerts.

4. Technical Reliability

Unstable internet connections, incompatible devices, or software conflicts can interrupt examinations and affect monitoring accuracy. These technical difficulties may prevent candidates from completing assessments or result in misleading activity records.

How to improve technical reliability:

  • Conduct device compatibility, internet connectivity, and software checks before examinations begin.

  • Establish technical support and examination rescheduling procedures for candidates affected by verified system failures.

5. Limits of Behavioral Interpretation

Smart proctoring systems can identify observable activities but cannot reliably determine a candidate's intentions. Looking away from the screen, speaking, or temporarily leaving the camera frame does not necessarily indicate cheating.

How to address behavioral interpretation limitations:

  • Evaluate flagged activities against examination rules and available contextual evidence rather than relying solely on automated detection.

  • Allow candidates to explain disputed incidents before making decisions that could affect their examination results.

How to Choose the Right Smart Proctoring Solution?

Choosing the right smart proctoring solution requires evaluating examination requirements, technical reliability, candidate experience, and data protection practices. Organizations should prioritize platforms that meet their assessment needs while ensuring fair monitoring and transparent review procedures.

Smart proctoring solution selection based on assessment requirements, technical reliability, and data governance.

1. Assessment Requirements and Fit

Different assessments require different levels of supervision. A professional certification examination may involve stricter monitoring requirements than an internal employee training assessment. Organizations should therefore determine which controls are necessary before selecting a platform.

  1. Specify permitted resources and prohibited actions before configuring examination controls.

  2. Choose a monitoring model suited to the stakes, purpose, and scale of the examination.

  3. Confirm that browser restrictions and monitoring controls will not block approved tools or accessibility accommodations.

2. Technical Reliability and Candidate Experience

A smart proctoring solution should function reliably across supported devices, internet conditions, and examination environments. Technical difficulties can disrupt assessments and create unnecessary stress for candidates, making pre-deployment testing essential.

  1. Request evidence of system performance across realistic devices, lighting conditions, and examination environments.

  2. Test accessibility, low-bandwidth performance, device compatibility, and technical support procedures.

  3. Pilot the platform with representative candidates before full deployment to identify potential usability and reliability issues.

3. Data Governance and Human Review

Smart proctoring platforms may process personal information and generate alerts that influence examination outcomes. Organizations should evaluate how this information is collected, secured, retained, and reviewed before implementing a solution.

  1. Check who can access examination recordings, how information is protected, and how long data is retained.

  2. Require documented human review before making significant decisions about suspected examination misconduct.

  3. Establish a clear process for candidates to question or dispute inaccurate findings.

Best Practices for Implementing Smart Proctoring

Implementing smart proctoring requires clear examination policies, defined responsibilities, and appropriate support for candidates. Organizations should follow a structured approach to ensure that monitoring practices are consistent, transparent, and fair.

Step 1. Establish and Communicate Examination Rules

Define the activities permitted during an examination, the monitoring technologies being used, and the consequences of potential rule violations. Inform candidates about identity verification, recording requirements, and technical expectations before the assessment begins.

Providing clear instructions in advance helps candidates understand examination requirements and prepare their devices and testing environments.

Step 2. Assign Responsibilities for Examination Review

Establish clear responsibilities for monitoring examination activities, reviewing automated alerts, and making decisions about potential misconduct. Authorized reviewers should assess relevant evidence and examination rules rather than relying solely on automated scores.

A documented review process helps maintain consistency and reduces the risk of unfair decisions based on incorrectly flagged activities.

Step 3. Provide Accessible Assessment Alternatives

Offer reasonable accommodations and alternative examination arrangements for candidates who cannot use standard monitoring methods because of disabilities, device limitations, or other legitimate requirements.

Organizations should establish procedures for requesting accommodations before examinations and ensure that approved arrangements do not unfairly affect candidates' assessment outcomes.

Step 4. Monitor and Improve the Proctoring Process

Regularly evaluate the performance of smart proctoring systems to identify technical issues, unreliable monitoring conditions, and unnecessary difficulties experienced by candidates. This may involve reviewing incident volumes, successful appeals, technical failures, and candidate complaints.

Use these findings to refine monitoring configurations, improve candidate guidance, and update examination procedures. Continuous evaluation helps organizations maintain effective supervision while reducing the risk of inaccurate alerts and unfair assessment outcomes.

Conclusion

Smart proctoring helps educational institutions, certification providers, and employers supervise online examinations through identity verification, digital monitoring, examination controls, and structured incident review. By supporting remote assessments, it can improve examination flexibility, simplify administration, and provide useful records for investigating potential rule violations.

However, effective smart proctoring requires more than automated monitoring. Organizations must address technical limitations, protect candidate information, accommodate accessibility requirements, and ensure that flagged activities receive appropriate human review.

By selecting suitable monitoring methods, establishing transparent examination policies, and maintaining fair review procedures, organizations can use smart proctoring to support examination integrity while protecting the candidate experience.

Abhishek Kaushik

Founder & CEO - Sherlock AI

Building fraud intelligence for live high-stake video interactions (financial discussions, hiring interviews, board meeting etc).

Catch candidate fraud before it costs you.

Sherlock AI helps you detect AI-assisted, proxy, and deepfake candidates, so every hiring decision is backed by evidence.

Ask AI about Sherlock.sh